#shanenaz2016

November 2016 - I and my pals cycled in The Galilee, Northern Israel, to raise money for Nazareth Hospital Paediatric Department. We raised over £50,000 but we could use more! Nazareth is the largest Arab town in Israel; the people are lovely, and the kids are awesome. Nazareth also treats kids in the West Bank of Palestine who have very limited access to healthcare. They need your help! Go to my sponsorship page to find out more and see what you can do! Maybe even join us in 2017..?
http://justgiving.com/shanenaz2016

10 April 2016

Electronic Health Record - #EHR4NI - a vehicle for Standardisation?

Prof Rafael Bengoa

As you might have gathered from earlier entries in this blog, we in Northern Ireland are embarking upon a journey which will (hopefully) lead to a unified health data structure across the whole region. There are a number of reasons why we want to get all our health (and social care) data into a structure that is operative across many sectors, that reduces duplication in data entry, that is up-to-date and accurate, and streamlines the whole process of health care. It Makes Sense.


The DHSSPSNI have recently given approval to a Strategic Outline Case (SOC) which proposes developing a detailed business case for procurement of what we're calling the #EHR4NI - Electronic Health Record for Northern Ireland. This is potentially momentous - if all goes according to plan (!), Northern Ireland will have a unified health record for all its citizens, incorporating such items as outpatient records, prescribing information, lab tests, radiology and much more. There is also the prospect of bringing Primary Care (GPs) and Community Services into the mix, but the precise scope and detail have yet to be worked out.

In many ways this work directly assists delivery on the Principles of the Bengoa Review. (This is a major review of Health & Social Care in Northern Ireland, mandated by the Minister Mr Simon Hamilton, and which is taking place at the moment.) I'll be blogging at some point on how the Principles align with the #EHR4NI project, but one element that has been prominent in discussions has been that of standardisation of medical care across NI.

I have to declare that I am a fan of standardisation, so long as we're delivering meaningful outcome measures that we can reflect on in an effort drive improvement. If we are all doing things (largely) the same way, we can analyse the outcomes for our patients, and react quickly if things are not going as well as we would like. That's all well and dandy, but if we're all doing the same stuff, can that limit innovation and hence prevent us discovering other ways of doing things even better? Can standardisation be the enemy of best care? If we end up valuing the cookie cutter more than the cookie, we run the risk of missing important insights, demoralising our inventive and innovative health practitioners, and stalling the progress that our patients rightly expect.

Here's my worry - in the rush for an EHR4NI, we may end up simply doing things the way a Big Vendor decides we should do things. We standardise our processes to the standards of the incoming system. The constraints of the IT solution translate into constraints that we have to apply across patient care, because we have no other option. If we go back to the suppliers to suggest a Different Way of Doing Things, we risk being met with stony gazes and the reply that the process is set in stone (near enough). Or if we go to our Department of Health, they respond with a massive governance ask (submitting things to committees and review bodies etc) that stifles the little shoot of innovation before it even deploys its first leaves.

Standardisation, in other words, can become the engine of conservatism, and prevent the very improvements we're trying to achieve with the EHR.

Now all that sounds very pessimistic. But here's another scenario - we simply don't get the required agreement across multiple Health & Social Care sectors to allow us to move to a unified system, people start fighting with each other, and the whole plan falls apart. That is quite clearly worse than standardisation itself - BUT it's an outcome that many other EHR implementations have experienced grief over. It's a likely scenario, not an unlikely one. That's scary, and we need to avoid that at all costs.

Let's re-state what we want: we want the best evidence-based patient care, we want the right information at the point of care, we want near-real-time analytics to let us know how we're doing and to spot problems early, we want systems to help us do our job, and to help our patients better manage their own healthcare. We also want the data to allow the big decisions about resource allocation to be made in an informed manner.

So how can we make standardisation a force for good, not evil? How can we make sure that innovation is rewarded, creativity is encouraged, and changes are properly evaluated? I think the way around this is to explicitly state that standardisation has to be something that emerges from the bottom-up, rather than being enforced from the top-down. The role of the health managers, civil servants, committees and so-forth must be to curate and cultivate the front-line activity, to facilitate sharing of process data and outcomes, and to assist rapid regional adoption of improvements, using the EHR as a key enabler. If we make sharing an explicit part of the process, we create an evolutionary system where continual improvement can be encouraged - possibly even become inevitable.

This may mean we need to look at the EHR differently. The EHR can't be a single monolithic computer system - although that's how many people think of it, it's not possible to achieve the aims of #EHR4NI using this model. Instead, perhaps a specific core system could carry out a large number of the administrative and core clinical informatics tasks, but other platforms and sandboxes could tap into the underlying data structure to allow new applications to be developed, and new ideas trialled. This can be done without having to subject everything to a slow conservative process where deviation from the Agreed Norm, while not exactly heresy, becomes so mired in procedure, that we can't move forward.

Maybe even these thoughts are themselves heresy. Surely the People At The Top know best? I wouldn't count on it. The history of major ICT projects is littered with tales of projects going belly-up because they were treated as ends in themselves, rather than as vehicles to bring real benefit to patients and staff. Let's make this project one that we can be proud of.

58 comments:

  1. Stop thinking of an EHR and start thinking of automation (out of which records will fall, and which will use them).

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Adrian, you're right - if we think of EHR, we risk confining our thinking to a monolithic system, instead of focusing on the overall framework into which our health data needs to integrate and flow. But we can't over-fragment either, as that is the road to gazillions of different systems that only pretend to talk to each other. Time to separate out the data, and get jiggy with OpenEHR or something similar. At least break the vendor lock-in, and deliver the wins quickly and with agility.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Totally agree, Shane!
    See more on the Postmodern EHR concept at: http://blog.marand.com

    ReplyDelete
  4. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  5. In the ken of electronics world only Custom Electronic design gives me exact solution. It's amazing in nature.Electronic consulting services is renowned services provider. If you to be part of this you will have to log in its web portal for further information..

    ReplyDelete
  6. Interesting blog! I loved your article and I found it so interesting. Your blog has the best topic I read and I got many good ideas here. I'm so lucky that I found your blog. I'm happy to share this site http://practicemax.com/
    because it has also information about ehr.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Now a days Electronic Health Records are implementing by several number of hospitals around the world. These can focus on the identification and analysis to search the previous studies on EHR implementation in the hospitals.
    hospital id bands

    ReplyDelete
  8. Get the best Treatment for the liposuction surgery in Delhi with reasonable Cost. We have the best liposuction surgeon within your budget. Get More Detail. 8750242000.
    More@ http://www.gocosmeticsurgery.com/liposuction.html

    ReplyDelete
  9. Finding tummy tuck surgery, tummy tuck surgery in Delhi with reasonable price and 100% Satisfaction Service. Compare all Clinics in Delhi, India- Price, Reviews, address, Maps and Photos. Contact us-8750242000.
    More@ http://www.gocosmeticsurgery.com/tummy-tuck.html

    ReplyDelete
  10. Me Clinic is one of the Reputed Clinic for Anti Aging Treatment in Delhi With Most Experienced and Skilled Surgeon, Lowest Cost, 100% Satisfaction Service. Compare all Delhi Clinics. Price, Reviews, Address, Maps and Photos. Contact us- 8447622467
    More@ http://www.meclinicindia.com/medi-facial.html

    ReplyDelete
  11. Thanks for taking the time to discuss this, would you mind updating your blog with more information? It is extremely helpful for me.

    Pellet Training for Physicians

    ReplyDelete
  12. You got a really useful blog I have been here reading for about an hour. I am a newbie and your success is very much an inspiration for me.

    Trocar kits

    ReplyDelete
  13. Looking for the best Clinic for pigmentation tattoo removal in delhi with Lowest Price. Me Clinic is the right place for Pigmentation tattoo removal in Delhi.Compare and Check- Lowest Cost, Most Experienced Surgeon, Proper Facility. Contact us-8447622467.
    More@ http://www.meclinicindia.com/pigmentation-removal.html

    ReplyDelete
  14. Top Cosmetic Surgery, Best Cosmetic Clinic in Delhi,india.Me Clinic is one of the best Clinic for Cosmetic Surgery in Delhi with Reasonable Cost.Compare all Clinics in Delhi- Reviews, Price, Proper Facility,Address, Maps and Photos. Contact us-8447622467

    More@ http://www.meclinicindia.com/

    ReplyDelete
  15. Cosmetic Surgery India is one of the Top Clinic for Breast Augmentation Treatment in Delhi with Affordable price.Check and Compare- Price,Reviews,Free consultation,Address,Maps and Photos.Contact us-8750242000.
    More@ http://www.cosmeticsurgeryindia.org/cosmetic-plastic-surgery/breast-augmentation.html

    ReplyDelete
  16. Hair transplants in Delhi. Book Doctor's Appointment Online, View Fees, User feedbacks, Address & Phone Numbers of Hair Transplant Surgeons in Delhi | Me Clinic
    More@ http://www.meclinicindia.com/hair-transplant.html

    ReplyDelete
  17. Hair transplants in Delhi. Book Doctor's Appointment Online, View Fees, User feedbacks, Address & Phone Numbers of Hair Transplant Surgeons in Delhi | Me Clinic
    More@ http://www.meclinicindia.com/hair-transplant.html

    ReplyDelete
  18. Natural Hair Transplant one of the top Hair Transplant Clinic in Delhi for affordable cost for hair transplant surgery, provides best results for Hair Transplant in Delhi.Call us-8750242000.
    More @ http://www.naturalhairhairtransplant.in/

    ReplyDelete
  19. Looking for breast lift surgery or sagging breast treatment in Delhi. Book your appointment with best breast lift surgeon to opt this Procedure in Delhi India.Call us-8750242000.

    More@ http://www.cosmeticsurgeryindia.org/cosmetic-plastic-surgery/breast-uplift.html

    ReplyDelete
  20. Looking for a best Laser Treatments For Skin Rejuvenation in Delhi,India. Visit Me Clinic and get cost effective laser skin resurfacing treatments.Call us: +8447622467
    More@ http://www.meclinicindia.com/skin-rejuvenation.html

    ReplyDelete
  21. Body Contouring Treatment in Delhi Plastic Surgery Clinic offers body contouring and liposuction procedures in Delhi for body fat and loose skin treatment.Call us-8750242000.
    More@ http://www.plasticsurgery.com.ng/body-contouring.html

    ReplyDelete
  22. Natural Hair Transplant one of the top Hair Transplant Clinic in Delhi for affordable cost for hair transplant surgery, provides best results for Hair Transplant Surgery By most experienced Surgeon.Call us-8750242000.
    More@ http://www.naturalhairhairtransplant.in/

    ReplyDelete
  23. Natural Hair Transplant one of the top Hair Transplant Clinic in Delhi for affordable cost for hair transplant surgery, provides best results for Hair Transplant Surgery By most experienced Surgeon.Call us-8750242000.
    More@ http://www.naturalhairhairtransplant.in/

    ReplyDelete
  24. Me Clinic provide Non Surgical Treatments in Delhi Like Acne and Pimple Scars, pigmentation Sunspots Freckles, wrinkles, tattoo removal, Chemical peel treatment in Delhi, India.Call us-8447622467.
    More@ http://www.meclinicindia.com/

    ReplyDelete
  25. Me Clinic provide Non Surgical Treatments in Delhi Like Acne and Pimple Scars, pigmentation Sunspots Freckles, wrinkles, tattoo removal, Chemical peel treatment in Delhi, India.Call us-8447622467.
    More@ http://www.meclinicindia.com/

    ReplyDelete
  26. Nose Surgery in Delhi, a most common surgery. Enhance your facial look by getting a suitable nose surgery with a best Rhinoplasty surgeon in India.Call us-8750242000.
    More@ http://www.cosmeticsurgeryindia.org/cosmetic-plastic-surgery/nose-surgery.html

    ReplyDelete
  27. Laser Hair Removal Procedure|Me Clinic
    Are you looking for pain free lowest cost Laser Hair Removal Procedure . Book your treatment plan with Best Medical Savings in Delhi and get best deal. Call Now -8750242000.
    More@ http://www.meclinicindia.com/laser-hair.html

    ReplyDelete
  28. Are you looking for pain free lowest cost Laser Hair Removal Procedure . Book your treatment plan with Best Medical Savings in Delhi and get best deal. Call Now -8750242000.
    More@ http://www.meclinicindia.com/laser-hair.html

    ReplyDelete
  29. Looking for rhinoplasty or nose surgery in Delhi. Book your appointment with best rhinoplasty surgeon to opt nose reshaping in Delhi India.Call us-8750242000.
    More@ http://www.nosesurgerydelhi.com/

    ReplyDelete
  30. Looking for rhinoplasty or nose surgery in Delhi. Book your appointment with best rhinoplasty surgeon to opt nose reshaping in Delhi India.Call us-8750242000.
    More@ http://www.nosesurgerydelhi.com/

    ReplyDelete
  31. Plastic Surgery Clinic is the one of the best clinic and hospital in Delhi for weight loss surgery including Gastric Banding Bariatric surgery, Mini Gastric Bypass and Gastric Surgery.Call us-8750242000.
    More @ http://www.plasticsurgery.com.ng/weight-loss.html

    ReplyDelete
  32. Plastic Surgery Clinic is the one of the best clinic and hospital in Delhi for weight loss surgery including Gastric Banding Bariatric surgery, Mini Gastric Bypass and Gastric Surgery.Call us-8750242000.
    More @ http://www.plasticsurgery.com.ng/weight-loss.html

    ReplyDelete
  33. Secure Medtrip offers Best Eye Surgery in India by Best Eye Surgeon in India, Best Lasik Eye Surgeon India, Best Laser Eye Surgeon India, Top Eye Doctor India With Reasonable Cost.Call us-8750242000.

    More@ http://www.securemedtrip.com/eye-surgery/

    ReplyDelete
  34. Secure Medtrip offers Best Eye Surgery in India by Best Eye Surgeon in India, Best Lasik Eye Surgeon India, Best Laser Eye Surgeon India, Top Eye Doctor India With Reasonable Cost.Call us-8750242000.

    More@ http://www.securemedtrip.com/eye-surgery/

    ReplyDelete
  35. Get the best Treatment for Cosmetic Surgery for Men Face in Delhi,India within Reasonable Cost.Me Clinic is one of the leading Clinic in Delhi for Cosmetic Surgery for Men Face.Check and Compare- Price,Reviews,Patients Testimonial. Call us-8447622467
    More@ http://www.meclinicindia.com/

    ReplyDelete
  36. Get the best Treatment for Cosmetic Surgery for Men Face in Delhi,India within Reasonable Cost.Me Clinic is one of the leading Clinic in Delhi for Cosmetic Surgery for Men Face.Check and Compare- Price,Reviews,Patients Testimonial. Call us-8447622467
    More@ http://www.meclinicindia.com/

    ReplyDelete
  37. Looking best brow lift surgery Clinic in Delhi, India. Cosmetic Surgery india Clinic Provide Specialist brow lift surgeon in delhi, brow treatment cost in delhi.Call us-8750242000.
    More@ http://www.cosmeticsurgeryindia.org/cosmetic-plastic-surgery/brow-lift.html

    ReplyDelete
  38. Looking best brow lift surgery Clinic in Delhi, India. Cosmetic Surgery india Clinic Provide Specialist brow lift surgeon in delhi, brow treatment cost in delhi.Call us-8750242000.
    More@ http://www.cosmeticsurgeryindia.org/cosmetic-plastic-surgery/brow-lift.html

    ReplyDelete
  39. Find the best Plastic Surgeon for Tummy Tuck Surgery in Delhi With Lowest Cost.Get a Perfect Tummy By Tummy Tuck Surgery in Delhi.Check and Compare- Price,Reviews,Free Consultation,Patients Testimonial,Address, Maps and Photos.Call us-8750242000.
    More@ http://www.surgerycosmeticplastics.com/our-services/tummy-tuck-abdominoplasty/

    ReplyDelete
  40. Find the best Plastic Surgeon for Tummy Tuck Surgery in Delhi With Lowest Cost.Get a Perfect Tummy By Tummy Tuck Surgery in Delhi.Check and Compare- Price,Reviews,Free Consultation,Patients Testimonial,Address, Maps and Photos.Call us-8750242000.
    More@ http://www.surgerycosmeticplastics.com/our-services/tummy-tuck-abdominoplasty/

    ReplyDelete
  41. Nose Reshaping in Delhi, a most common surgery. Enhance your facial look by getting a suitable nose surgery with a best Rhinoplasty surgeon in Delhi,India.Check and Compare-Price,Reviews,Patients Testimonial, Free Consultation,Address and Photos.Call us-8750242000.
    More@http://www.nosesurgerydelhi.com/

    ReplyDelete
  42. Nose Reshaping in Delhi, a most common surgery. Enhance your facial look by getting a suitable nose surgery with a best Rhinoplasty surgeon in Delhi,India.Check and Compare-Price,Reviews,Patients Testimonial, Free Consultation,Address and Photos.Call us-8750242000.
    More@http://www.nosesurgerydelhi.com/

    ReplyDelete

  43. Finding neck lift surgery in delhi and neck lift plastic surgery delhi specialists? Contact Cosmetic Surgery India Clinic as best neck lift surgeon in Delhi,India.Check and Compare- Price,Reviews,Free Consultation, Patients Testimonial, Address and Photos.Call us-8750242000.
    More@ http://www.cosmeticsurgeryindia.org/cosmetic-plastic-surgery/neck-lift.html

    ReplyDelete

  44. Finding neck lift surgery in delhi and neck lift plastic surgery delhi specialists? Contact Cosmetic Surgery India Clinic as best neck lift surgeon in Delhi,India.Check and Compare- Price,Reviews,Free Consultation, Patients Testimonial, Address and Photos.Call us-8750242000.
    More@ http://www.cosmeticsurgeryindia.org/cosmetic-plastic-surgery/neck-lift.html

    ReplyDelete
  45. Finding neck lift surgery in delhi and neck lift plastic surgery delhi specialists? Contact Cosmetic Surgery India Clinic as best neck lift surgeon in Delhi,India.Check and Compare- Price,Reviews,Free Consultation, Patients Testimonial, Address and Photos.Call us-8750242000.
    More@ http://www.cosmeticsurgeryindia.org/cosmetic-plastic-surgery/neck-lift.html

    ReplyDelete
  46. Find the best Clinic for Laser Treatment for Skin Cancer with reasonable Cost.Check and Compare- Price, Patients Testimonials, Reviews,Address, Maps and Photos.Call us-8447622467.
    More@ http://www.meclinicindia.com/

    ReplyDelete
  47. Find the best Clinic for Laser Treatment for Skin Cancer with reasonable Cost.Check and Compare- Price, Patients Testimonials, Reviews,Address, Maps and Photos.Call us-8447622467.
    More@ http://www.meclinicindia.com/

    ReplyDelete
  48. Looking for the best Clinic in Delhi for Laser Treatment for skin Pigmentation by Specialist Surgeon.Chk and Compare- Price,Patients Testimonial,Reviews,Address,Maps and Photos.Call us-8447622467.
    More @ http://www.meclinicindia.com/pigmentation-removal.html

    ReplyDelete
  49. Looking for the best Clinic in Delhi for Laser Treatment for skin Pigmentation by Specialist Surgeon.Chk and Compare- Price,Patients Testimonial,Reviews,Address,Maps and Photos.Call us-8447622467.
    More @ http://www.meclinicindia.com/pigmentation-removal.html

    ReplyDelete
  50. We offer reasonable and best mommy makeovers surgery, plastic surgery for mommy makeover after child birth which helps women transform their bodies after baby.Check and Compare- Price, Patients Testimonial, Free Consultation Fees,Reviews,Address, Maps and Photos.Call us-8750242000.
    More@ http://www.plasticsurgery.com.ng/mommy-makeover.html

    ReplyDelete
  51. We offer reasonable and best mommy makeovers surgery, plastic surgery for mommy makeover after child birth which helps women transform their bodies after baby.Check and Compare- Price, Patients Testimonial, Free Consultation Fees,Reviews,Address, Maps and Photos.Call us-8750242000.
    More@ http://www.plasticsurgery.com.ng/mommy-makeover.html

    ReplyDelete
  52. Natural Hair Transplant Clinic is one of the best Hair Transplant Clinic in Delhi for affordable cost for hair transplant surgery by Cosmetic Surgeon.Call us-8750242000.
    More@ http://www.naturalhairhairtransplant.in/

    ReplyDelete
  53. Looking for cosmetic surgery in this winter season? Book your consultation with Dr. Ajaya Kashyap (M.D, FACS) Plastic surgeon or call +91 9958 22 1983 to schedule an appointment. http://www.drkashyap.com/

    ReplyDelete
  54. Do you need best hair loss treatment in Delhi? KAS Medical Center is the perfect choice, We offer you the best hair transplant surgery at affordable cost. Book your consultation now!
    View: http://www.besthairtransplantdelhiindia.com/

    ReplyDelete
  55. Right treatment at right time with right dermatologist botox treatment KAS Medical Center.Book your appointment call us - +91 9958221983 / 81

    ReplyDelete
  56. Do you need best gynecomastia surgery in Delhi? KAS Medical Center is the perfect choice, We offer you the male breast reduction surgery at affordable cost. Book your consultation now!
    View: http://www.bestgynecomastiaindia.com/

    ReplyDelete
  57. You can undergo cosmetic plastic surgery in Delhi and discover a new side of your personality. There are different types of cosmetic surgery procedure to improve the shape and appearance of body parts. Rhinoplasty Surgery South Delhi

    ReplyDelete
  58. Nice Blog, Thank you for sharing such a important information about Chemical Peels Treatment

    ReplyDelete